Is A Barrel Tile Roof More Secure Than A Metal Roof?

Is your roof in need of a replacement and you are having difficulty deciding which type of roof tiles to replace it with? If so, you are not alone, because thousands of homeowners are faced with this same issue each year. This is a very difficult decision to make, especially if you are unfamiliar with the types of roofing tiles that are available on the market. Below, you will discover the answer to “is a barrel tile roof more secure than a metal roof” and much more.


Slate and clay tiles have been utilized for many decades to secure home from the elements. It is obvious how durable these tiles are, since they were capable of withstanding decades of Mother Nature’s elements. Of course, technology has taken the tile roof to a whole new level. The clay tile is very expensive and out of reach for most homeowners, so manufacturers decided to eliminate this issue, by developing plastic and concrete tiles. This type of roofing tiles are much more affordable, but they be lacking in durability and longevity.

Extremely Heavy

Roofing tiles can definitely transform any ordinary home into a Spanish veranda, but they are very heavy. Much preparation is required, before the installation process begins. The roof must be reinforced with additional supports, just to prevent the roof from collapsing. Most roofing companies offer this service, along with the installation, so do not fret.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing has become extremely popular, because it offers a lifetime of 50 years or longer. The metal is very appealing and available in various colors, so it can be enveloped into the design of your home. Metal is a lightweight material, so there will be no need to make any roofing support alterations. This alone will make the metal roof much more affordable and within reach of many homeowners.


When comparing the metal roof and roof tiles, it can be challenging. The roof tile is available in two different styles, flat, barrel, and pantiles. The flat tiles are very easy to install, since they lay flat on the roof in an overlapping fashion. The pantiles are a little more difficult to install, since they must be hooked together, but this is necessary to keep them flowing in a straight line and secure.

The tile roof has a natural ventilation system, which allows air to freely flow underneath the tiles. This not only aids in keeping the attic cooler, but will aid in keeping them secure on the roof during a natural disaster. Roofing tiles have undergone extensive testing and it was proved that they are capable of withstanding winds up to 150 miles per hour.

When installing a metal roof, the panels are overlapped and screwed down with metal screws or nails. While the metal offers longevity, it is questionable how well they can withstand hurricane winds. If the metal panels are not secured properly to the roof, it is possible for wind to get underneath the panels and rip it right off of the roof.


It answer to the question “is a barrel tile roof more secure than a metal roof” is obvious. The barrel tile roof appears to be much more secure and can withstand very high hurricane winds.